Guide

The Starbucks Roastery ruling protects the dress policy, not the shirt

The Second Circuit sent Starbucks' shirt rule back to the labor board with a three-factor test. That test tells an owner what belongs on the page that ships with a box of staff shirts, and where the page stops helping.

· 7 minute read

In Siren Retail Corporation, d/b/a Starbucks Reserve Roastery v. NLRB, decided September 2, 2026, the Second Circuit rejected the labor board's test for dress codes and told the Board how to judge Starbucks' shirt rule instead. The new test asks three questions about a dress policy, and none of them is about the garment. An owner about to hand a crew, a gym or a shop a box of Employee T-Shirts can use it as a checklist for the page that ships with the box. For a shop of eight, the court matters less than the floor: the evenness a court checks is the same evenness that makes a crew look like one crew.

The Second Circuit upheld one Starbucks pin rule, sent the shirt rule back, and binds three states

In the Starbucks Reserve Roastery case, the Second Circuit upheld a Starbucks limit of one union pin, rejected the National Labor Relations Board's 2022 Tesla standard, and sent two other dress rules back to the Board: the Logo-Shirt Policy and a rule against pins that advocate a political, religious or personal issue. The case began on September 19, 2022, when employees at the Roastery's main coffee bar in New York City wore Starbucks Workers United T-shirts over their aprons and a manager told them to change under the Logo-Shirt Policy, which allowed a small manufacturer's logo and no unapproved colors, designs, logos or writing. Tesla presumes that a mandated uniform code violates federal labor law and requires the employer to tailor it narrowly, and the court held that the test fails to properly balance employer and employee interests.

Where an owner operates decides which test applies. The Roastery ruling binds the Second Circuit: New York, Connecticut and Vermont. The Fifth Circuit, sitting en banc in Tesla, Inc. v. NLRB (2024), vacated the Board's Tesla ruling and rejected its standard, and that circuit covers Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi. SHRM's report on the ruling notes that Tesla remains the Board's precedent until the Board replaces it. An employer in Florida or California, outside both circuits, answers to that standard if a charge is filed.

The Second Circuit's three factors measure a shirt rule's reach, evenness and setting

The Second Circuit told the Board to judge the Starbucks Logo-Shirt Policy on three factors, in Siren Retail Corp. v. NLRB, No. 24-3168 (2d Cir. Sept. 2, 2026). The first is how far the rule intrudes on employee rights, including whether it is a full or partial ban during working time. The second is whether the policy is facially neutral, nondiscriminatory and consistently enforced. The third is the context of the restriction.

The one-pin limit shows how a written rule fares under those factors. It survived because its wording closely matched a rule the Second Circuit upheld in its 2012 Starbucks decision, where the court found Starbucks "entitled to avoid the distraction from its messages that a number of union buttons would risk." The court compared text with text. An unwritten habit can be applied just as evenly, but its reach is whatever a manager said on a given day, and the owner has nothing to set beside a precedent.

Attorney Hunter Yoches of Bass, Berry & Sims told SHRM, in its report "Federal Appeals Court Rejects NLRB's Strict Dress Code Standard": "Facially neutral, consistently applied policies grounded in legitimate business interests now stand on stronger ground." The same report warned that enforcing a rule selectively against union supporters still invites challenges.

A staff shirt wear rule covers five things, and the fifth carries the rest

A one-page wear rule for staff shirts says when the shirt is worn, which shirts count, what goes with it, how many each person gets, and who the rule covers. Each item takes a sentence or two, and the page belongs before the order, because it sets the count, the colors and the garments.

When: name the occasion, such as customer-facing shifts, events or Saturdays, or say plainly that the shirt is optional. A narrower occasion intrudes less, which is the court's first factor.

Which shirts: list every approved design and color by name. One design printed on a black tee and a heather gray long sleeve in the same order gives two approved shirts, and the page should name both.

What goes with it: say what may be worn over the shirt, such as aprons, jackets or hoodies. Any wording about pins, buttons or union apparel belongs with the company's employment lawyer, because federal labor law governs it, and the attorneys in SHRM's report stress that such rules should cover all non-approved messages the same way rather than single one out. The Starbucks rule that won outright allowed one union pin, in writing, alongside company pins.

How many: state the count per person and that every new hire gets the same count in the first week, then order for the team plus the next hires in one run, since a small reorder carries its own setup and costs more per shirt.

Who: the rule applies to everyone on the schedule, owners and managers included. This is the item the court's second factor tests, because a policy that excuses the people who enforce it is neither neutral nor consistently enforced. An owner who works the counter in a hoodie while the crew wears the shirt has made an exception the page does not show. A business whose crew already wears its shirts under a dress code that works may need no new order at all, only this line added to the code.

A voluntary shirt with no mandate is the strongest case against a written wear rule

The strongest case against a written wear rule is that the safest staff shirt, outside the Second and Fifth Circuits, may be one nobody is required to wear. The Board held it unlawful for Tesla to require employees to wear a plain black T-shirt or one with the company logo, and in most of the country a charge is judged under that standard. A shop of eight could hand out the shirts, require nothing, and give a labor board nothing to read.

The objection is right about the mandate and wrong about the page. Writing the shirt rule down does not create the Tesla risk. Requiring the shirt does. The page cannot make a mandate lawful: a required shirt with a well-written page is still a required shirt. Outside the Second and Fifth Circuits, optional is the lower-risk word, and a written rule can say exactly that while still naming the approved shirts and binding the owner to the same terms. A voluntary shirt with no page has no edges, so a manager who asks one person in a union shirt to change has enforced a rule that exists nowhere. A logo shirt required every shift, with nothing else allowed, is the kind of rule the Board found unlawful under Tesla in the Roastery case, a finding the Second Circuit refused to enforce and sent back for the Board to decide again. An employment lawyer should read that rule before the box ships.

On the courtroom, the objection holds: most small crews will never test a dress rule before the Board. The page earns its place on the floor, and the Roastery record puts the floor and the court on the same facts. On September 19, 2022, a group of employees at the main coffee bar wore black union shirts over their aprons, the crew behind one counter split by shirt, and a manager decided who had to change. The court's second factor asks whether the policy behind that call is facially neutral, nondiscriminatory and consistently enforced, which means whether the rule that reached that group reaches everyone. A crew asks the same question every shift, and a rule that bends for the owner answers it badly whether or not a charge is ever filed. An optional shirt the owner wears every shift unites a staff better than a required one the owner skips.

Writing the shirt rule down does not create the Tesla risk. Requiring the shirt does.

The Board will judge the Starbucks shirt rule again under the court's three factors, and that answer may take longer than a print run. An owner does not need it to write the one line no ruling on remand will make wrong: the rule binds everyone on the schedule, starting with whoever signs the order.

Further reading

  1. SHRM, report on the Second Circuit's rejection of the NLRB's Tesla dress code standard, with employer counsel commentary on neutral, consistently applied policies shrm.org/topics-tools/employment-law-compliance/federal-appeals-court-rejects-nlrbs-strict-dress-code
  2. National Labor Relations Board, news release on the 2022 Tesla decision on union insignia and uniform T-shirt policies, the standard the court rejected nlrb.gov/news-outreach/news-story/board-rules-workplace-policies-limiting-wearing-union-insignia-including

Have an idea for your shirts?

Tell us what you have in mind. A designer turns it into a design for you to approve, and you can call us anytime during business hours.

Request Free Mockup